Last night at dinner we were having a salad.
“I always put too much lettuce in”, I said, looking at the salad.
“But it’s a salad. It’s supposed to have lettuce,” said Adam.
“Does a salad have to have lettuce?”, I asked. It was a serious question. But then I was like, “I know. It is a salad. It should have lettuce”. Resigning myself to the fact that it is indeed a salad and it *should* have lettuce.
But REALLY? Does a salad HAVE to have lettuce? (I think the answer is no, in fact, I’ve eaten plenty of salads that didn’t).
What I’m asking is really: Do things HAVE to be a certain way? Does art always have to be like that? Does music always have to have a verse, chorus, verse, bridge, chorus? Does poetry always have to rhyme or follow some sort of pattern? Do you always have to do things a certain way in a certain order for it to have a certain outcome? Does a salad really HAVE to have lettuce in order to be a salad? (I’m asking a lot of absolutes here, I realize).
“Does everything have a formula?
The way in which things work best?
If you break the formula,
You have a mess.
Keep to the formula and life will work out.
Art is not only a discipline,
But there are rules,
And breaking them
Creates chaos
For the consumer.
Lines, shape, color, negative space, poetry rhythms,
storylines, music composition, mathematics, business, dance,
The formulas are all there.
Even the natural world, the universe,
A complex rhythm of formulas,
All working together.
The surface may look ike there’s no order,
But dig deep and you will see
There’s a formulas for everything
(Even you and me)”
Is there a natural way that things have to work? Algorthims, a recipe, a form, a pattern, the way that things have work in order to have a certain outcome?
No and yes.
No, because there is freedom in expression, and expressing ourselves in art. We can do whatever we like, there’s no right or wrong way, it’s what we make it, it’s how we like it.
But yes. If I try to bind a book contrary to a certain formula (And there are lots of them), it won’t necessarily be a book, will it? I can use different materials (Leather, fabric, wood, paper, etc), but the essence is the same. It’s a book. You can read it left to right or right to left, it can have words or pictures, be interactive, a manual for reference or a school texbook, but the essence is the same. It’s a book. There are pages bound together that you can flip through; which makes it a book.
I find myself in the tension of formulas vs. freedom a lot. I agreed with my husband that a salad did indeed need to have lettuce, but something in me was just resigning myself to that. I either didn’t want to argue, or kew that the conventional American salad was with mostly lettuce and veggies.
There is a process in the way I make books. And I’ve found it. I like it. A forumula for making journals gives me freedom to create within a boundary. There is no boundary to the cover design or what I put IN the actual journal (Pockets, folded pages, pictures, words, memorabilia, found items, etc), but the process of making it is the essentially the same. Which leads to structure and confidence in my art.
If I have no structure, no process, no forumla, no boundaries, then it’s just chaos. Right? As I said in my poem, breaking the ‘rules’ ‘creates chaos for the consumer’ (Whether or not we are selling our art, if we share it with someone, that person becomes the consumer).
If we create chaotic art, then do we have confidence in what we’re doing? If I don’t know what I’m doing when it comes to binding a book, the process seems messy and stressful and the outcome may not be what I hoped, However, if I DO know what I’m doing, have a process and formula, a GUIDE, a set of steps to lead me through the creating of a new art piece, then I can confidently go to work on it, enjoy myself while doing it and have a relatively pleasing outcome.
And yet, I’m all in favor of pushing those boundaries, even though pushing boundaries is a weakness in me. I don’t do it. Or if I do, I certainly don’t do it often enough.
Half the time I’m just trying to get what I see in my head OUT of my head. I don’t necessarily think my personal process of making journals is exactly pushing any type of boundaries in the bookbinding world. But I enjoy it. And maybe as I continue to gain more skill pushing boundaries will come and I can create new boundaries.
Again, doing the best with where we’re at.
